Amynka / OGame: Moon Spy and Recycler

  1. OGame: Moon Spy and Recycler
  2. Issues
  3. script stolen
Open Closed
Marti Admin

Re: @Black_Cat:

I'm original author of this script. It is available here: https://greasyfork.org/fr/scripts/4444-ogame-moon-spy-and-recycler with correct use of @require tag.

It would appear that you are not the original author of this script.

  • The original author is neither one of you from what I can tell... The earliest ScriptWright that I can find is Appels in 2007 at http://userscripts-mirror.org/scripts/show/12318.html in 2007 in which you copied it in 2009.
  • Somehow you published it on gf in August 23, 2014 yet Amynka published July 19, 2014.
  • From this information it is possible to deduce that you have broken the "rules" of gf. Open-source is just that... our licensing terms are available here. If you wish to pursue this on the grounds that it is... it has already been minimally shown as not being your script. You must follow the DMCA to pursue this further.

Imo there is no merit for this allegation.

Black_Cat Author

Re: @Marti:

The original author is neither one of you from what I can tell... The earliest ScriptWright that I can find is Appels in 2007 at http://userscripts-mirror.org/scripts/show/12318.html in 2007 in which you copied it in 2009.
I didn't even know this script... The name looks like but the content is not the same at all!
Somehow you published it on gf in August 23, 2014 yet Amynka published July 19, 2014.
I published this version of my script on userscripts.org in October 24, 2013 (http://userscripts-mirror.org/scripts/versions/54541.html). I published the script on greasyfork because userscripts.org is down.
Amynka published the script here and only changed author's name and @require tag (this tag is not used correctly as I said). I don't mind if someone makes a fork of my script to improve it, but this is exactly the code of MY script with different author's name!!

Black_Cat Author

Re: @Marti:

The original author is neither one of you from what I can tell... The earliest ScriptWright that I can find is Appels in 2007 at http://userscripts-mirror.org/scripts/show/12318.html in 2007 in which you copied it in 2009.

I didn't even know this script... The name looks like but the content is not the same at all!

Somehow you published it on gf in August 23, 2014 yet Amynka published July 19, 2014.

I published this version of my script on userscripts.org in October 24, 2013 (http://userscripts-mirror.org/scripts/versions/54541.html). I published the script on greasyfork because userscripts.org is down.
Amynka published the script here and only changed author's name and @require tag (this tag is not used correctly as I said). I don't mind if someone makes a fork of my script to improve it, but this is exactly the code of MY script with different author's name!!

Marti Admin

Re: @Black_Cat:

I published this version of my script on userscripts.org in October 24, 2013

No you published it on USO on Jul 26, 2009 23:31... anyhow you know the routine as I posted above... if you wish to pursue this that is how you do it. Just because your script on gf is now nearly in sync with this one doesn't necessarily mean anything specific to your allegation. I've already examined it and your USO script is a derivative of at the very least Appels which there is also anoter reference to another ScriptWright there. This issue is closed with OUJS admin... if you would like I can message Jason to have your script removed from GF for violation of his terms based off of the available information... but I think you should just accept the credit given in this one. Like I said it's unusual that GF shows your script is newly published compared to this one... our date is correct and verified... so must be an issue over at gf. It's your choice.

Black_Cat Author

Re: @Marti:
Re: @Marti:

No you published it on USO on Jul 26, 2009 23:31...

I'm talking about a specific version of my script, the one that Amynka copied here. If you compare my script from userscripts.org and this one you will see they are identical.

if you would like I can message Jason to have your script removed from GF for violation of his terms based off of the available information...

Which violation?? I'm clearly the author of this script from all evidence provided. I have the right to publish my script on another place that userscripts.org since the website is down...

And here at http://userscripts-mirror.org/scripts/show/7467.html would be the OgamerNLs original... lots of derivatives since then for sure.

Did you compare this script with mine? The name is similar but content is totally different.